top of page

The Modern Lovers: The first New Wave band?

jamesgeraghty
3 minutes ago
6 min read

As ever, we are asking the questions no one else can be bothered with. This time the question being asked: were the Modern Lovers the first New Wave band?

And I guess to start answering this question, we need to know what the music genre of New Wave actually was.


What actually is New Wave?

New Wave emerged onto the music scene in the late 1970s, broadly off the back of the Punk movement that had ruffled the scene's feathers across 1976 - 1978. It was characterised by a more melodic, some may say arty, sound - a little bit of the underground, quite a bit of pop, some electronic stuff and a dose of punk. 


It emerged in two main centres. The now legendary New York City scene, centred around clubs like CBGB’s and Max’s Kansas City, and led by the likes of Blondie, Talking Heads and The Cars, joined from Ohio by Devo and from Georgia by the B-52s. Meanwhile, a little more spread out in London and beyond, you had British options like Elvis Costello & The Attractions, The Police and XTC.


So, how do The Modern Lovers fit into all this?

Way, way back in 1970, in the small town of Natick, Massachusetts (just west of Boston), a nineteen year old wannabe musician, Jonathan Richman, formed the Modern Lovers. They would later be called a proto-punk band (once we knew what punk was), and had an infatuation with the Velvet Underground.


The Modern Lovers: Hospital (video made for the song)


Singer and guitarist Richman was, by 1971, joined by the ‘classic’ line-up of David Robinson on drums, Ernie Brooks on bass and Jerry Harrison on keyboards (the latter two were students at Harvard). Robinson would later help form the The Cars, while Harrison would become a Talking Head - so you can maybe start to see how the premise of this article might have arisen.


Richman had already penned several of the songs that have since become renowned, like Roadrunner, She Cracked and Hospital. The stage presence he would become known for was already starting to be developed; jacket and tie on stage, songs with often improvised lyrics and monologues.


They soon built up a strong local following and quickly found their name mentioned in record company circles. In fact, by the end of 1971, Stuart Love at Warner Bros. Records had already got them into Intermedia Studio for their first session (which gave us Hospital). These demos, coupled with their live reputation, was getting others interested in them too. 


They went to Los Angeles in 1972 for two sessions; one was for Warner Bros. with the Velvet Underground’s John Cale producing (giving us versions of Roadrunner, She’s Cracked and Old World); the other session was with Allan Mason for A&M. The two sessions would later be combined to make an album, released long after this line-up ceased to be. The tracks recorded stood out for being out of step with the popular tunes of the time - their take on Velvet Underground simplicity stood apart from the glam rock of T-Rex, hard rock of Led Zeppelin, and the prog rock of bands like Yes and Genesis. 


The Modern Lovers: She's Cracked (audio only)


There were more demos done, this time a bunch of tracks were laid down in 1972 with Kim Fowley, which would ultimately appear as The Original Modern Lovers album in 1981. The problem was, the band just couldn’t get themselves a record deal for love nor money. 


When they did finally sign to Warners in 1973, Richman then decided on a musical change of direction, deciding to ditch all of those early songs and move towards a more relaxed sound. This change forced Warner Bros hand to drop the band (this was not the sound they had signed them for) and led to them breaking up in early 1974.


The Modern Lovers: Girl Friend (audio only, live at Berkeley, 1972)


Later Lovers

A few years later, Richman would put a new version of the Modern Lovers together, but this time as his backing band. Original drummer David Robinson returned (briefly), along with Greg Keranen on bass and Leroy Radcliffe on guitar. It was now all about mixing 50s rock n roll with harmonies, and being unafraid of borrowing music from across the board, covering others (Chuck Berry), taking traditional tunes (Amazing Grace) and older popular tunes (Emaline etc). By now, he was giving us emotional honesty, delivered in an almost childlike manner, focusing on positivity and beauty.


Jonathan Richman and the Modern Lovers came out in May 1976, strangely three months before those original songs from five years earlier were also released (when they finally were put out by Beserkley).


Influence

Those earlier tunes were seen by some as being a key part of the burgeoning punk scene. Roadrunner made it to number 11 on the UK chart when it finally surfaced in 1976, whilst the instrumental Egyptian Reggae made the Top 10. Both the Sex Pistols and Joan Jett covered Roadrunner (John Lydon once apparently called it his favourite song), and critic Chris Colin even referred to Richman as the Godfather of Punk.


Sex Pistols: Roadrunner (live in 2007, a slightly lyrically freeform interpretation)


Many from the world of Alt-Rock owe a debt to him and the band, from the Violent Femmes and They Might Be Giants, to Pixies and Weezer. There was also an overlap into rap, when M.I.A. included Roadrunner lyrics in her song Bamboo Banga (on her 2007 album Kala).


New Wave or not New Wave?

Looking back, William Crain at Furious, saw the Modern Lovers as the only worthy successors to the Velvet Underground, taking and progressing that fairly simple sound. He saw that Richman understood how the Velvet’s had “used simple sounds and rhythm to build excitement and to communicate complex emotions.”


Many firmly put that early Modern Lovers stuff down as proto-punk. Nashville Scene referred to that early version of the band, said that they were helping to “codify punk rock during a time when most North American fans were still in thrall to Peter Frampton, Bob Seger and Linda Ronstadt.”


The Modern Lovers: Astral Plane (audio only)


So, while we don’t normally think of new wave bands until much later in the 70s, could this bunch of New Englanders have really created this genre more than half a decade earlier? They bridged the past, present and future; they had “an appreciation of the past and the way it can continue to inform and enhance the beauty of the present.” 


There was none of that excess which was so common for the early 70s; what they did was straightforward, simple and direct. Jerry Harrison brought an art-school aesthetic with him, keeping his keyboards tight within the rest of the songs, just like he would later on with Talking Heads. Sister Ray has a simple chugging progression, Girlfriend is stripped down and quiet in tone, while Astral Plane nods to something more lo-fi.


Then there is also that aforementioned fact of those direct links with the main new wave scene - namely Harrison being in Talking Heads and Robinson helping to form The Cars. But you can hear their arty sounds all the way through to much later bands like Car Seat Headrest and Parquet Courts.


Perhaps, you could argue (quite logically), there is always the middle ground, as posited by Blakemadsblog - that the Modern Lovers sit somewhere in between, in “a no man’s land between proto-punk and new wave.” This can be backed up by the fact that the punks liked them (and covered them), while the definitive new wavers (Talking Heads etc) picked up on the lighter and occasionally whimsical aspects.


The Modern Lovers: Roadrunner (audio only - an absolute classic)


But for me, since I asked the question, I will give my (kind of) definitive opinion.


While those early songs would eventually be released right in the middle of what was developing into the punk and new wave scenes of 1976, the fact that they had been recorded four years earlier, surely makes them a strong candidate to be considered the original new wave band.


Okay, and also maybe they were the first punks too - I mean She's Cracked matches up pretty well with anything by the Pistols, but it is also quite a bit like I Wanna Be Your Dog, which had already been around a few years. So, maybe I stretched that one a bit - they were almost the first - you have to have Iggy Pop, MC5 and a few others on that list before them.

Photo: from the Modern Lovers website
Photo: from the Modern Lovers website

Comments


© 2022 by DREAMING OF BIRDS THAT ARE BLUE. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page